Top 5 College Admissions Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Join college admissions expert, Dr. Katie Chiou, to learn how you can sidestep common application pitfalls and stand out in the admissions process.

What you’ll learn:

– The most frequent application mistakes students make – and how to avoid them.
– Effective strategies for crafting compelling essays and personal statements.
– How to navigate extracurriculars and recommendations to strengthen your application.
– The role of deadlines, organization, and preparation in your success.
– Tips for standing out at competitive schools while maintaining authenticity.

This webinar is your opportunity to gain valuable insights, ask questions, and confidently take the next steps toward your dream college. Don’t miss it!

Date 11/03/2026
Duration 1:01:38

Webinar Transcription

2026-11-3-Top 5 College Admissions Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Anna: [00:00:00] Hello, everyone. Good evening, or afternoon, or morning, whatever time it is from wherever in the world you’re joining us, we’re so happy you’re here for our webinar, “Top Five Admissions Mistakes and How to Avoid Them.” My name is Anna Vande Velde, and I’ll be your moderator today. I’m a Senior Advisor at CollegeAdvisor and have been with the company for five years now.

Anna: To orient everyone with the webinar timing, we’ll start off with a presentation, then answer your questions in a live Q&A. On the sidebar, you can download our slides, and you can start submitting questions in the Q&A tab anytime, so you don’t need to wait until the very end of the webinar to send us your questions.

Anna: Just to know, if they’re super, super specific, um, about your exact situation, this probably won’t be the best format to get into them because those tend to require a discussion. But we’ll talk about later on an opportunity to meet with us [00:01:00] one-on-one and ask exactly those types of questions. Um, but for tonight, as best you can, keep your questions generic enough that you think they’d be helpful to other students joining us.

Anna: Uh, I think that’s all the housekeeping for now. So it is my pleasure to introduce your speaker tonight, Dr. Katie Chiou. Katie, could you please share a bit about your background?

Dr. Katie Chiou: Yes. Hi, everyone. Excited to be here tonight. Um, so I’m Katie. I have been working with CollegeAdvisor for, uh, like, gotta be, like, maybe seven years now, and a couple of years before I rec- I started with CollegeAdvisor, so I’ve been working admissions for quite a while.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, I went to Brown for undergraduate as well as for medical school as part of a combined BSMD program called the Brown Program in Liberal Medical Education, which is what you see here. Um, and am now a second-year resident at Mount Sinai. [00:02:00]

Anna: Thank you so much, Katie. We’re really lucky to have you. Before we get into your presentation, I thought it might be helpful to get a sense of who’s joining us, so I’m gonna open this poll.

Anna: Please let us know, um, what grade you are in. If you’re here as a support person, you can select other. And while we wait for those results, Katie, given tonight’s topic, can I ask you, are there mistakes you think you made when applying to colleges? And if so, which one stands out the most?

Dr. Katie Chiou: I think one of the ones that I made was applying to too many schools.

Dr. Katie Chiou: I applied to, I think, over 30 schools, and part of it was a little bit of the fear-mongering. Like, I think, I think as the season went on, I get, I got more and more anxious, and I started applying to schools that I really wasn’t that interested in or schools I applied to just because they were free to apply to.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, and, and retrospectively, I was like, “I don’t know why I applied to so many schools.” It felt like it was, [00:03:00] you know, it was like fe- fear had overcome and, and then I hadn’t done a lot of research into these schools, and really couldn’t think about, like, why I wanted to go. Um, so that would be, I think, one of the things that I would have taken a step back on and been like, “What, let me check myself and see if I actually wanna go to the school that I’m applying to, or if I’m just doing it because I’m scared I’m not gonna get in anywhere.”

Anna: Yeah. That’s great advice. I really challenge my students to, even when they’re looking at safety schools, let’s make every school on your list a place you think you’d be excited to go, because that’s gonna make all the work of the application worth it. Um, all right. It looks like we have enough answers to our poll.

Anna: Almost half of the folks joining us are in 11th grade. So that makes sense, they’re thinking ahead. We have about 10% are seniors. Um, about 20% are in 9th and 10th grade, so really thinking ahead. We’re so happy you’re here. And then a quarter said other, so likely educators, parents, guardians, [00:04:00] um, folks like that.

Anna: Thank you all for being here. I’m gonna close the poll, and then Katie, I’m gonna hand it over to you for your presentation.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Perfect. All right. So today the topic and, and of, of the webinar is going to be about college admissions mistakes primarily. And I think throughout this webinar we’ve weaved in a little bit of also of my application, kind of like what I did when I was applying to colleges, and I’m hopeful that having those more like concrete examples will be helpful.

Dr. Katie Chiou: But the first thing I think is, is to address kind of the title of this webinar, which is to say like addressing mistakes I think is something that’s ultimately sort of a fear-mongering point, um, in admissions. And I know a lot of you are juniors out there and probably a little bit anxious about the time ahead and thinking about application season coming up.

Dr. Katie Chiou: So I’m glad that you’re all here tonight ’cause I’m hopeful that I can be… I’m, I kind of think of myself when it comes to admissions as a very blunt person. Um, so we’ll, we’ll get into all the details there. Um, but I think [00:05:00] there’s like a spectrum of like, you know, you go to these talks and people start to overvalue or over talk about certain things.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Like peop- I, I’ve had students come to me and like, “Oh my gosh, I heard that colleges track if you, if you tour the school, and if you’re showing interest in the school, and if you email this person, and how many times you email them.” And then it becomes like, you know, like superstition built upon superstition.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, I can say equivocally that I, um… I’m from California. I applied prim- I applied to like almost all the Ivy League schools and a lot of East Coast schools. Did not step foot into a single East Coast school. My mom’s whole motto was like Don’t y- we’re not, we’re not flying there until you can get in, and then we can go there and see if you like it.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, and, and still I got into a lot of the East Coast schools, right? So the … I think it becomes, like, this building of like, “Oh my gosh, I need to do all these things in order to get in.” Um, and then it becomes kind of a monster in, in your head. And the second thing I’ll say is that it’s a really long process, and so, um, I’m happy to hear that a lot of you out there are starting early and are get- taking the time to kind of think about things ahead of time and plot, plot out, like, [00:06:00] classes, think about extracurriculars ahead of time, and also kind of get these questions answered, um, early on so that, you know, you don’t have to be fearful then later on.

Dr. Katie Chiou: So the first mistake, and this is the one that I think is the biggest and also the most able to be addressed, especially by the time that students are coming to me as an advisor, um, is the essays, right? For a lot of you out there who are juniors, um, let me think. Yeah, so if you’re juniors, I’m, I’m assuming that a lot of you guys, um, maybe know that essays exist but haven’t started working on them, haven’t started thinking about them, haven’t looked at the prompts yet.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, so this is just to kind of get set expectations for ahead of time. And then for any seniors out there who are in the midst of writing essays, um, this, I think, will be very, very key, which is to think of essays like a portfolio. What I mean by that is that people often don’t realize that there are actually a lot of essays when you’re applying to colleges.

Dr. Katie Chiou: I remember going in, I thought it was just the one personal statement. No. It turns out, for example, for Brown alone, um, I believe that I wrote five essays for the undergraduate, um, portion, and then I wrote two additional essays [00:07:00] for the medical program that I was a part of, which is to add up to seven essays.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And the essay count has, I’m, I’m sure, changed since then. But just to get a sense of, like, for one school alone, I was writing seven essays. Now, you can reuse essays. That’s not absolutely not a bad thing. They’re not, like, co- comparing and contrasting, oh my god, did this person sh- like, write the same essay?

Dr. Katie Chiou: But right, the essay prompts ultimately are different. And so you will end up writing a good number of essays in order to apply to all the schools that you wanna be applying to. And so with that in mind, I want all of you to think about essays, let’s say, like, I’m gonna use Brown as an example ’cause that’s where I went, but seven essays as a portfolio or s- a stock portfolio, meaning some of the essays you might take higher risk on and some of the essays you might play it safer on, right?

Dr. Katie Chiou: Like, just like, just like you would with money. You, you buy some, like, high-stake stocks, but then you might invest in some, like, you know, like, safe, like, you put it in a savings account for a rainy day. Um, same idea because with all the different essays, there are opportunities where you can really let certain things shine.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Maybe you pick a [00:08:00] very, uh, a riskier topic. Um, uh, the example that I have here is I remember one of my roommates at Brown wrote about learning to bike for the first time, and y- that’s, like, a very mundane activity most people, not myself unfortunately, but most people have learned how to bike. You’d be like, “Why would someone choose to write an essay about that?”

Dr. Katie Chiou: There’s something in that essay that was telling about who she was Where she grew up and what that experience was like that she had woven into her essay. So that’s maybe like, for example, a tiny bit of a riskier topic choice. I wrote an essay, I remember, in the form of an autopsy of myself, and it was supposed to be kind of like a tongue in cheek.

Dr. Katie Chiou: I don’t know what I was thinking, but I really liked forensics and, like, I watched a lot of, like, Criminal Minds shows when I was young, and so that was something that I wanted to fold, like a personality thing I wanted to fold into an essay. That was an example of a risky format, right? Like the wrong person, I think written in a weird way could have been, come off as like a little bit weird and dark, right?

Dr. Katie Chiou: And, and like maybe with a red flag, but I made it mostly humorous and I used it to address other things in my like, uh, [00:09:00] as like, like a ver- like more plain things. I think I used it to address like extracurriculars and the way that my mind worked. It was like an autopsy, but it was more of like a, as if it could scan my mind and understand how my mind worked, and that was how I was trying to explain how my brain worked.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, and then there are safer essays. I often think of my personal statement essay, um, as a safer essay. It was about an extracurricular that I did that was very prominent for me, um, I, where I worked at a suicide hotline, um, that was run by teenagers for teenagers. Um, the topic of the essay I thought was relatively safe.

Dr. Katie Chiou: It was about an extracurricular that I volunteered at, that I like, you know, really cared about. Um, the, the place where I took the risk with that essay was that I wrote it in a slightly different format than most people write a personal statement. Most personal statements, um, typically start with some sort of challenge.

Dr. Katie Chiou: They have a climax, and then they kind of like culminate in a lesson. My essay had a little bit like of different stories from other people interspersed, different stories that I’d listened to while I was working at the suicide hotline. Um, and that was a [00:10:00] harder essay to massage into working from like just a literary formatting standpoint.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, all to say that some essays are going to be safer. My Why Brown essay, for example, was incredibly safe. It was just about what classes I would be interested in, showed that I did my research into Brown and why I wanted to go, and trying to, you know, tell them why I was a, like I was a good fit for the school.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And so the, the point being that essays should, one, not all be about the same thing, and two, like there are ways that you can take risk and also, y- you know, have some riskier essays, have some safe- safer essays all for the same school because they’re gonna read through all those essays all at once, and they’re kind of getting a, a picture of who you are and also, you know, the person that you are, the activities that you’re involved in, what you do in your free time, and how you might fit in on their college campus.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Okay. I think one mistake that I see the most frequently, I think the one– like, and the one that I almost always call out. Um, so in my time working as an advisor, I worked with a lot of pre-med [00:11:00] students, as you might imagine, as someone who is now a doctor. Um, I worked with a lot of pre-med students and also engineer- students interested in engineering or in STEM in general.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And one thing that I often see is that students think that, um, they need to repeat themselves or repeat their intellectual interests in order to make it known to the admissions officer. So for example, a lot of my pre-med students will write about their interest in medicine in nearly every single essay.

Dr. Katie Chiou: There’s no need, right? ‘Cause if you think about it, someone’s reading this in 15 minutes. I remember that in essay, like, two you mentioned that you were interested in pre-med. You don’t have to mention that in essay one through seven. Like, I got it. Um, take the time. Again, it’s a portfolio. Use the, the, use the space to show different aspects of yourself and highlight different parts of your application, different parts of how you grew up and who you are, um, such that you can flesh out.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And, and ultimately the goal is to have an admissions officer really, like, essentially, like, like you. Like, you want them to be convinced that they would want you as a student at their college, so they can go on to [00:12:00] fight for you in the next rounds of admission to be like, “Hey, I think that this kid really should get in,” and you’re memorable in their mind in that 15 minutes of reading the application.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, and, and to be totally honest, that repetitiveness about someone’s interest in their career, oftentimes it becomes very surface level, and then it becomes repetitive to the point where I’m like, “I already know what you’re gonna re- what you’re, you’re gonna write,” and it’s almost, like, very predictable.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And in some ways, trying to showcase who you are and add an element of surprise even into an essay, I think can make a very effective essay. When, when I’m reading essays and I’m like, “Whoa, I didn’t expect you to write about that,” or like, “There were some risks that you took that surprised me,” it makes you, one, all the more memorable, but also two, I’m usually impressed.

Dr. Katie Chiou: I’m like, “Oh, I’ve read so many essays that if someone can surprise me,” I’m like, “Whoa, that stood out to me.” Um, thinking about how you can add your own voice to it, that’s like one way that people can surprise me. Some people have like, you know, more tongue in cheek humor. One of my, um, pre-med classmates I remember really loves puns, and she wrote an essay about her love of puns, and obviously interspersed a ton of puns [00:13:00] in her essay.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, and that was a way that she highlighted her own personality. Um, you can– Yeah, there’s like so many different ways that you can make essays your own, with different formats, different structures, the choice of content, what topic you pick, you choose to talk about. Um, but the point is that I wanna get across is that there are many essays and there are many different ways that you can tackle each and every one

Dr. Katie Chiou: Mistake number two, and this is for especially those of you who might be freshman or sophomore out there, juniors too as well, but thinking about your extracurricular profiles, uh, profile early on. Um, the thing that I wanna make clear is that there are actually only 10 spots on your Common Application.

Dr. Katie Chiou: So if you are killing yourself doing like a bajillion extracurriculars, remember that at the end of the day, there’s only 10. And, and when I say only 10, at first people are like, “Oh my god, that’s a lot.” But that, that includes a lot of things. That includes, for example, if you babysit in your free time, that includes your part-time job, that includes like things that you do during the summer.

Dr. Katie Chiou: So like maybe you do like [00:14:00] one-off things here and there during the summer. That includes like clubs that you are in school. That includes volunteering or achievements that you’re a part of. That includes like projects that you might be a part of, right? So it actually adds up pretty quickly. Um, and people who like play an instrument or do a sport, and each sport counts as separate extracurricular, it can add up pretty quickly.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, so but the main thing to know is that there are 10 spots. No more, no… Well, there are less. But the ideal number is that you fill out all, all 10 and, and kind of try to communicate to admissions officers what is it that you’re doing with your free time. And if that’s working a part-time job or watching over your siblings to help support your family, that also should be there because that is how you’re spending your fam- your time, right?

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, and think of it also as like trying to create a profile of yourself. I remember when I was doing my extracurriculars, I really like thought of them, and I ended up thinking about them kind of in like lumps. So I had, um, my working the suicide hotline and my interest kind of in mental health. I looped that in a little bit with, oh, my interest in, um, [00:15:00] the brain and neuroscience and, and s- more like science and biology stuff.

Dr. Katie Chiou: So I was the captain of my Science Olympiad team, and that was something that was talked about in my application a bit. Um, and the other lump I thought of as like my humanities side. I’m al- I’ve always been a more humanities person. I detest math and chemistry. Um, and so I entered like writing competitions.

Dr. Katie Chiou: I was the editor-in-chief of my school’s literary magazine. So that’s like a separate lump. And then I had like a lump that like didn’t really fit any anywhere, but I was just trying to like tell them something about me. I had like an extracurricular that was about like my background in music. So like the fact that I had played piano and that I had taken singing lessons and didn’t do anything with it.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Like, I wasn’t a part of any orchestra. I didn’t sing in any choirs. But it was just there because, again, it was a way I spent my time and it’s something I was interested in. Um, but that actually all comes together, um, and not every extracurricular is gonna fit in beautifully. Um, and e- even looking back, I can see different ways the different things connected.

Dr. Katie Chiou: But, um, I think that lumping, uh, together of things really made a difference when [00:16:00] I was actually writing my essays and pulling it all together. Um, in my personal statement, I talked about my interest in mental health, encountering, um, kids who had had abusive histories, and then thinking a little bit about development of language.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And when I applied for college, I actually, um, at the time applied as a cognitive science major with a focus in linguistics. That’s not what I ended up majoring in. Um, another big like misconception, I think- Is that what you apply as what you must go in as? No. At most schools, you actually don’t declare a major until the end of your sophomore year.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, so despite the fact that I applied as a cognitive science major, as soon as I stepped foot onto campus at Brown, like that, that major designation was erased. Like, no one ever thought of me as a cognitive science major, and I didn’t, I didn’t, I just took classes that I wanted to take, and I declared my major at the end of my sophomore year.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, but the reason for that, in case, hopefully I was trying to build an argument for why I did a cog sci with linguistics, with linguistics major, was because I was trying to argue for, like, look, I have this interest in the biological [00:17:00] aspects of the brain, and then look, I also have this interest in words and in language.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And I was able to talk about how working on the suicide hotline, you know, all you have is words. Um, and, and I’m someone who’s still fascinated by words and language. It’s why I became a psychiatrist and, and kind of like thinking about words and language as the main modality of treatment that I have Okay, mistake number three, underestimating letters of rec.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, I would say, so think about it as you need at least one humanities and one STEM teacher. Typically, for most schools, they’ll typically have s- around, like, three letters of rec. But at the very least, you want one humanities and one STEM teacher, and your last one could be, like, an extracurricular, um, leader.

Dr. Katie Chiou: It could be someone from a sports team. It could be someone, you know, like, outside of school, or it could be someone in school, another teacher. Um, but at the very least, you wanna, you wanna think about these two ahead of time because you know they’re gonna be there. Um, some tips I have for that. [00:18:00] You wanna choose a teacher who knows you as a person.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Maybe it’s someone that, like, you hang out with at lunch, like you eat… You know, like, you and your friends, like, hang out in their room, and you eat lunch there. I don’t know if that’s not cool, a cool thing to do anymore, but, like, back when I was in high school, like, sometimes we would do that. Um, but it’s, like, teachers who maybe get to know you as a person better, not just the teachers who you do their best in their classes.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Because at the end of the day, you don’t want your letter of rec to just say, “Oh, like, so and so has 100% in my class.” That’s fine. That’s cool. But honestly, like, that doesn’t really tell me anything about you. You want a teacher who’s gonna comment on, like, the way you think and who you are, maybe how you interact with other students, like a time in which you’ve helped the teacher out or stood out in some way, um, about how you think about the, about, like, academics.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And so i- ideally, you’re thinking ahead of time. Another tip that I have is to maybe ask upperclassmen, like, “Who’s known to write a good letter of rec?” And I think you’ll find that they often have an [00:19:00] idea. Like, it’s someone, usually teachers, who are willing to put more time and are good writers who are writing these letter of rec.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, and, and usually people have a sense of who that might be. Um, you also might think about a teacher who, right, is, like, the, is, like, the sponsor of your robotics club or is, like, a mentor of some kind to you in some of these, um, extracurriculars that you are a part of. So I will say for me, for example, I, I often think that…

Dr. Katie Chiou: And I, I have no way of knowing this, but I think letters of rec, people tend to say, like, they count for, like, maybe 5% of your application. I have this, like, feeling that at, at least for me, they made a much bigger impact than that. And the reason for that is because I think if you get a truly stellar letter of rec, your admissions officer, whatever, put your admissions officer hat on, and you get a truly stellar letter of rec, it, like, shines, and this person is raving about you, um- That’s gonna stand out.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Like, that’s going to stand out from the pile of other letters [00:20:00] of rec from teachers who are writing like, you know, like, “Oh, so and so is a great student. Like, they are always on time to class, and they’re very attentive to their classwork,” right? Like, to have something more beyond that that’s, like, raving about you, that’s going to stand out, and I have a feeling that these letters of rec actually made a huge difference in me getting into some of the schools I got into.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, a- and I do have, uh, like, my evidence for that is, um, one of my teachers, for example– Or after I graduated high school, both of my teachers gave me their letters of rec so I could read them sort of as, like, a graduation gift. And one of them I remember was, like, multiple pages long and, and talked a little bit about what I did as a captain of, um, my school’s Science Olympiad team.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And w- we were an under-resourced team. We didn’t really have the materials and the supplies that a lot of other, um, schools in my area had, um, and certainly not the parental support either. And he– I don’t know. He really gassed me up, basically. Like, he made me sound really good. And there’s also a lot of admin stuff that I was taking care of as the captain.[00:21:00]

Dr. Katie Chiou: And I remember that after I got in, um, I think it was, I think it was with Princeton. I feel like, uh… Well, I think it was both Yale and Princeton. Like, they made a little note, ’cause after you get in, they write you a little note of, like, “Oh, my gosh, congratulations.” Like, I particularly, like, made note of, for me, it was, like, my work in Science Olympiad.

Dr. Katie Chiou: I remember being kind of surprised, because I think for Yale, like, I didn’t talk anything about Science Olympiad in any of my essays. And then for Princeton, I wrote, like, an essay about how I felt, like, I, I failed as a captain and, like, what I learned from that experience. Um, and so I– that’s, that’s kind of like my unofficial of, like, a letter of rec when it’s truly shining and outstanding can, like, make a human impact on an admissions officer and can make all the difference in terms of getting into these schools where a lot of other people have really great grades, um, and, and, you know, really great scores.

Dr. Katie Chiou: So again, not to, not, uh, to not underestimate the human impact of things. Um- Okay. Mistake number four, and this is addressing test [00:22:00] optional policies. I was at the question of like what test score do I need to get into Harvard? And I wish I had an answer. Like I- if I had like a, a number, I com- I, I would have put it this, put it on the slide.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, unfortunately, it doesn’t quite work that way. Um, I think of tests and grades kind of like a gateway, if that makes sense. Once you reach a certain threshold, we are all aware that it was kind of a matter of like, did you have a good day or not? Maybe you slept well the night before. Maybe you just got really unlucky with the reading comprehension section, and you had no clue what was going on, right?

Dr. Katie Chiou: Like, like those things happen when it comes to, to, to the, these standardized tests. That’s not to say they aren’t important, though. Standardized tests are one of the only ways that we have to assess, um, students across like different schools and different backgrounds. Um, again, like there was a big fight for, especially during, I think during COVID, a lot of schools went test optional, and I’m finding that schools more and more are coming away [00:23:00] from that.

Dr. Katie Chiou: So, um, they wanna see a test score. Even if the schools are still test optional, a lot of them are, are going back to requiring tests. But, um, even if a school is test optional, they do wanna see a test. Um, I would highly recommend that people take Um, either an SAT or the ACT, like practice test. Take it at home, see which one you vibe with more, see which one you like better, like it’s just like better s- you’re better suited for.

Dr. Katie Chiou: For me, it was the SAT. For a lot of people I know, it was the ACT. Um, whichever one you, you vibe with more, study hard for it, and then take it. And, and leave enough time for yourself to take it a number of times. Like, I would say, um, a- three times are like a, a golden number for how many times people take the SAT or ACT, um, just to have like, you know, you can have a super score at the end of it as well, meaning like they take the best scores of each of your sections and then add it all together.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, so I would think … I would, I would highly recommend that everyone start, uh, like plan for and prepare to take the test. And if the scores really end up not going the way [00:24:00] that you want them to go, then just speak with an advisor about whether or not that’s a school that you might wanna go test-optional for, um, depending on how, how it goes.

Dr. Katie Chiou: I would also recommend if any of you are taking AB- APs or IPs at your high school, um, any kinds of like s- like those kinds of, um, curriculum where they have standardized tests, I would recommend taking the test as well. So for, for me, my high school only had APs, and so one of the things that I really thought about was taking the correlating AP test, right?

Dr. Katie Chiou: Because I, I’m sure a lot of you have, y- know this as well, like not every … Like for example, one math teacher who’s teaching Calc AB is not equally a easy grader as the other teacher who’s teaching Calc AB, right? They might be like really … One teacher might be way harsher than the other teacher, and that’s what the AP tests are for, is to kind of help like assess, okay, so maybe one teacher’s a really easy grader, but then you are not learning calculus whatsoever in that class.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Well, that would affect on the AP test. Um, and so that’s why I think it can be really helpful for [00:25:00] especially like top-notch schools to be able to see like the AP/IB scores. Uh, and I should go back and say, and, and also think about depending on what you are interested in, what your strengths are, um, you can, you know, like focus in on, hone in on those AP tests.

Dr. Katie Chiou: So if, if you’re thinking about majoring in STEM, for example, then I would highly encourage you to have calculus under your belt if you’re thinking about pursuing like higher STEM education. Um, or if you’re really interested in English, right, the, like the two AP English classes, the APUSH classes, like those are all ways that you can show, um, strength in those areas.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Okay. Mistake number five is thinking about a school-specific fit. So this is addressing more of my juniors out there, I think, but also addressing a little bit of what I was talking about as like my mistake. Um, I wish I had done more research into colleges when I was applying. I kind of just like applied randomly based on what schools I had heard of and knew of and like that my classmates were applying to, and that was a huge loss, I think, [00:26:00] ultimately, because I’m, I’m applying from California.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, or I was in California at the time, and that’s where I grew up. And so I didn’t know about a lot of the schools on the East Coast, and I wish I had done a little bit more research, um, especially into liberal arts schools, um, that like are like, like the really good liberal arts schools that I simply just like hadn’t really heard of.

Dr. Katie Chiou: So if I could go back in time, I would, I would do a little bit more of that. But what I’m talking about when it comes to school research is thinking about how you were going to be a fit to their campus culture. So even amongst, for example, the Ivies, um, each of the Ivies kind of like has their own culture.

Dr. Katie Chiou: It becomes very prominent, I think. Or it becomes more prominent once you like step foot on their campus. And I, you know, maybe call me a like a, maybe it’s like magical thinking, but I am a strong believer that, um, the college that you go to actually does shape a lot of your personality and your career and who you become.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And so thinking about what are like the vibes, what are the stereotypes of each of these [00:27:00] schools? Um, even amongst … I, I’m gonna use the Ivies ’cause that’s where I went, and like that’s what I have a good example of. Um, so starting with like how to get in. Before even like is there … Are they a good fit for me, how am I a good fit for them, right?

Dr. Katie Chiou: That comes through in these, these essays that almost every school has, which is like I call them the why school essays, which is like why do you want to come to Brown? Why do you wanna come to Harvard? Why do you wanna come to Dartmouth? Why do you wanna come to blah, blah, blah. Um, and you would typically have to write an essay basically making an argument for why you are a good fit for their campus.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And you want to do your research. You want to research what that school has to offer and what might be particularly a good fit for you as a student. Um, ways that you can do that, I think, um, when it comes down– I had some, like, nitty-gritty things. One is to talk to alumni from your school. They can often be really helpful in, like, kind of talking about what that college is like.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Into nitty-gritty, I mentioned Facebook for events. Maybe, mm, actually I’ve, I’ve… It’s been a [00:28:00] while since I graduated from college, so they might have moved on to, like, Partyful or something. But if there’s a way in which you can do research into what events on campus look like and what, like, are, is prominent at that school.

Dr. Katie Chiou: I know, for example, at Brown, um, we always got to see, like, there was, like, a really cool theater, um, like, theater contingency where people would pr- like, make and produce and act and scriptwrite and do all these really cool events that I would always attend. Um, so if you’re into that, like, you might do research into that.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, like, there’s, like, our film club is very prominent or con- like our, um… We put on a spring concert every year, and those, like, it’s really competitive to get into that club. Um, and you have, really have to be, like, a tastemaker, for example, to be… So, like, kind of like you c- you get a sense of, like, what the vibes are.

Dr. Katie Chiou: So, like, that contingency, like, the arts people at Brown, they were, like, the cool kids. Like, they are tastemakers. They’re, like, on top of… They’re the people who are, like, creating, like, the new Spotify playlists and, like, discovering new music for the rest of [00:29:00] the world. Um, or, like, the culture magazine writers, right?

Dr. Katie Chiou: And, and that’s different culture from, um, some, like, some of the other Ivies. Um, and so it’s, like, thinking about, um, what you can learn about a school a- and how you can embed that into your essay. Uh, and the reason why you do that is because when you’re doing research into a school and writing that into your essay, what you’re showing is that you actually really are interested in the school.

Dr. Katie Chiou: The more, like, on point your essay is, the more the admissions officer is like, “Oh, I can envision you at this school, and also I can tell that you really wanna come here ’cause you did your research.” Um, and yeah. So, like, I wrote here as an example, I, I used Brown and Harvard because one of my best friends went to Harvard, and it’s, like, they’re very close to each other, so I was– I visited often.

Dr. Katie Chiou: But, like, even just stepping foot on campus, I was like, “Oh, there is a difference.” Um, Brown is very… I felt it was, like, a very student advocacy-focused school. It was very, like, um, rah, rah, like, how can we benefit people? Like that, that kind of stuff. Harvard, I remember, like, watching one of my best friends change going through [00:30:00] Harvard, and it was very much like, it really taught you how to be charismatic, how to make connections, how to talk to people and, like, you know, like, kinda like l- that, those kind of leadership strengths and skills.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, a- and those were, like, notable things that I noted out of, as, like, a different vibe out of the two schools. Okay. So how can you actually address those mistakes during the admissions process? Um, I guess here’s where it kind of went into, like, general tips, which is the best application is always going to be the one that’s genuine.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And in fact, when I’m reading through an application, that’s kind of, like, like it or not, that, that’s, like, what I am looking for. When someone tells me about their interest in XYZ thing, I’m always looking to dig deeper to see, like, h- how, how has this person shown that they’ve put thought into why they’re interested in that?

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, and that kind of gets to my, like, second and third point, which is that the biggest and best thing that you can do as a junior, as a [00:31:00] sophomore, as a freshman in high school is to develop that, like, self-reflective and introspective capacity. And granted, yes, am I a psychiatrist saying that? Yes, I am. Um, also though, I have been saying this for years in this, in this business, which is to say, like, the more you can think on yourself and, and kind of, like, reflect on, like, why do you wanna do something?

Dr. Katie Chiou: And, like, what is it that you wanna do? Why do you wanna do that thing? Um, and also it’s okay to second-guess yourself. Like, I certainly second-guessed, um, being pre-med multi- multiple times, definitely in high school, also in college. Um, and I didn’t apply pre-med actually to most of the schools that I applied to.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um- But, but also say like, right, it’s, it’s about like can you- second guessing yourself and trying to, like, understand your stuff. Because I think that actually comes out, the people who are best able to reflect on themselves and their lives and have that insight, it comes out beautifully in the essays and it, and it really makes for that extra, like, [00:32:00] that extra oomph that I’m looking for often when it comes to, um, reading about, like a, reading through an application.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, and in terms of like specific tips that I offer for that, I remember I, I often, like ’cause I commuted a lot during the summers, um, and even I just commute a lot in general. LA has traffic. Y- y’all know this. Um, and I would like take notes on the notes app on my phone. I still have some of those notes.

Dr. Katie Chiou: iCloud is, is, is nuts. Um, yeah, I would like take like little notes, like every time I would like think about my- I still do this actually. I literally did this the other day on the train ride home from work, um, is like to think kind of like as I’m thinking about myself, like think out loud and write down those things into a notes app.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, but it’s not that may- maybe someday it’ll turn into essay, but maybe someday, like it’s just kind of like me iterating on myself and trying to figure out what I can write about and what I can’t write about and like what would make sense. Um, I remember in, I, I wrote here, like in my sophomore year actually, I was trying to enter a writing competition, so I was like writing [00:33:00] an essay about an ex- like a s- the summer extracurricular that I, I did that year.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And huge chunks of that essay actually ended up making it into my, um, Brown Pleme essay. And so I guess, s- some, some people argue it’s never too early to start writing. I would argue even more strongly, it’s never too early to start brainstorming and, and kind of like thinking about what you would wanna talk about and thinking about yourself in general and like- your life.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Some of the questions that are the hardest for students are questions like, “What’s a time in which you’ve stood up for something you believed in? What’s a time in which you disagreed with something and, like, stood up for it? What’s a time, like, what’s a time in which you’ve gone through something difficult in your life, and how did you grow from that experience?

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, what is a unique perspective that you have on the world based on, like, how you grew up?” Um, so those are some of the, like, the tougher questions that I often hear, like, students come to me and are like, “Oh my gosh, these are really hard questions.” Those are the things that I would start thinking about early on.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And it’s okay if you ask other people for help. Like, ask your parents, [00:34:00] ask friends, like, like, “What’s interesting about me? Like, what stands out to you about me? Like, what makes me, me even?” Um, and that’s where it gets my first point, which is that sometimes it can be really difficult, um, for all my parents out there, like, I worked- I used to work as an advisor and worked with parents obviously as well, and talked to parents.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And it can be tough to find that, like, place of freedom, like letting your kid have freedom and also, like, making sure they’re staying on task. But it’s also one of those things where I find more often than not that there becomes a lot of tension in there. That’s why having a third party come in who’s objective and is not so emotionally connected to the whole business can be really, really helpful.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, but to say that, um, yeah, sometimes, like, I remember my mom was like, “What, like, you should definitely write about hiking,” because the metaphor of hiking, about climbing uphill and then tasting the sweet… What did she say? Like, tasting the sweet gives of the downhill. Like, that’s a metaphor for [00:35:00] hard work and for life.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And I was like, “Mom, no.” Um, she actually ultimately never read any of my essays and, um, she kind of gave me the freedom to be a little bit more hands-off and, and, you know, write my essays, apply to where I applied to. But I think one thing that my mom did that I was very, very grateful for was… Actually, College advisor wasn’t, didn’t exist at the time.

Dr. Katie Chiou: But, um, she did find me someone who, actually in my case was, like, a old English teacher who was working the business, who, um, was able to read over my essays and be, like, that voice of reason. And also importantly for me and for any of you who are, like, burgeoning writers out there, was someone who didn’t change my voice.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, you need someone who’s gonna be able to write in the style that you write in. And I remember even as a high schooler, I had a sense of, like, there were some people who were, as they were editing, just, like, completely changed, like, the style of my words. And you need someone who you can trust, who you can go to who won’t do that, kind of like understand what you’re trying to say and your ideas, and can work with you on that [00:36:00] Okay.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, finally, other resources that you ha– Yeah, I had that here. A few trusted advisors. Also, not too many cooks in the kitchen, right? I, I say, like, three people going through your essays is about, like, a golden number again. Three is a, like, a golden number, I guess, oftentimes. Um, other students. If you can talk to upperclassmen, that can often be the most– That can be so, so helpful to hear, like, what they did, what their extracurriculars were.

Dr. Katie Chiou: That’s where actually I– That’s how I found, um, my maj- like, one of my major extracurriculars is su- working at the Suicide Hotline, which, you know, has clearly been very instrumental to me as I am now working in the mental health field. Um, but, um, yeah, keeping your ear to the ground and seeing what other people are saying, even just about things like, “Oh, who’s an easier teacher?”

Dr. Katie Chiou: Like, “Who’s, who’s an easier grader?” Like, “Which teacher’s a better writer or rec writer?” Like, “Who’s nicer?” Like, those kinds of things can be so immensely helpful. Um, yeah

Anna: Thank you so much, Katie. That’s the end of the presentation part of our webinar. [00:37:00] We hope you found all that information helpful. Reminder, you can download the slides from the link in the Handouts tab.

Anna: And this is being recorded and will be emailed to everyone who registered, and will also be published on the CollegeAdvisor website, so you can look back, um, if you’re trying to remember what was discussed. We’re gonna move on now to the live Q&A. I’ll read through each question. Um, I’ll read it out loud and put it in the chat so everyone can both see and hear them before Katie responds.

Anna: Thank you for sending in questions live. We also have questions from when you registered. We’ll get through as many as we can. As a heads-up, if your Q&A tab isn’t letting you submit questions, just make sure that you join the webinar through the custom link in your email and not from the webinar landing page.

Anna: All right. I think that’s all I have to say, so I’m gonna dive into our first question, Katie. Mm-hmm. How much do you think a few Bs in rigorous courses will affect a [00:38:00] student’s chances at a top college?

Dr. Katie Chiou: Okay. That’s a good question and also one that I get quite often. Um, so I think we’ll start with, let me address the rigorous course part of it first, which is always this question of like, “Should I take an AP or should I take like a, a regular level class if I know the AP’s gonna be a lot tougher and I might get a B in it?”

Dr. Katie Chiou: And I think at the end of the day, colleges do wanna see, especially if it’s in a field that, you know, you’re thinking about and going into, they wanna see you challenging yourself. And, and The other thing that people don’t often realize is you’re also– they’re being sent a profile of your school. So for example, if you are saying, “Hey, I want to major in electrical engineering.”

Dr. Katie Chiou: I’m making this up. And, um, at your school, AP Calculus is being offered, but you opted… Well, that’s not a good example ’cause it’s not regular calculus, I don’t think. Well, maybe there is. Um, a- and but there’s like a, like a class level, like a sophomore level, or no, a senior level [00:39:00] calculus being offered. Um, and you are trying to decide between the two, but you wanna major in electrical engineering at a top school, right?

Dr. Katie Chiou: They might be like, “That’s weird. Why didn’t you opt for the AP version of that? Because you are trying to major in a tough major at a top school, I wanna see you at least attempt that challenge.” And, you know, there’s– we, we look at the bigger scheme of things too. Maybe you’re taking a ton of APs that year, and you got a B in one of them.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Okay. Like I, y- I can understand why you were juggling all of these things at once and why, um, that might have been a tougher cla- tougher class. Um, so I’ll start with that. Second thing is that they do look at kind of grade, grade trajectory over time. So, you know, sophomore year might be the first year that you’re taking multiple APs, and then junior year you might be like ramping up, right?

Dr. Katie Chiou: So thinking about that overall trajectory as well. And the last thing I’ll say is kind of more of like an anecdotal story, which is that, again, um, oftentimes people don’t realize that admissions officers are assigned to your local region or area. [00:40:00] So for example, for me, I went to high school in Los Angeles, and so there was an admissions officer who was assigned to like this one p- like a, a portion of Los Angeles.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And I remember one of them actually came in and spoke to us once and was talking about this history teacher that we have, who they’ve noticed over time, like not my year, like over literally years of working in that area, that this was a teacher who frequently gave out really tough grades for students who were otherwise essentially straight A students.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, and I remember there was this girl in like, I think it was a class above me, who was a straight A student, but got a C in AP US History. And everyone was like, “Oh my God,” like, like, “A C,” like, “Is that gonna be the end of the world?” Like, “How are they gonna get into Ivy…” Oh, I already spoiled it. They got– She got in.

Dr. Katie Chiou: She went to Harvard. Um, but I remember everyone was like, “Oh my God,” like, “You can’t get into a top Ivy League school with a C.” But this was a case of, right, the admissions officers actually might know your school, and in this– in my [00:41:00] case, like knew that specific teacher and knew how harsh of a grader it was, so they like was able to give that class some more context.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, even outside of that, like with, with Bs, like a couple of Bs, like there’s context for it. I’m looking, I’m zooming out and looking at, hey, like what was, what were the other classes you were taking? What were the extracurriculars you were balancing that year? Like maybe there were life circumstances. Um, and so those were all things that admissions officers are taking into account.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, that being said, I’m not saying that grades and test scores are not important in admissions. They absolutely are. Like I was describing, like, kind of like that gateway situation. But again, like, I think, um, it’s not as if having one or two Bs is going to kill your application. Um, that would … Yeah, like isn’t, not go- is gonna kill your application for a top school.

Dr. Katie Chiou: I would hazard a strong guess that out of, like, you know, my 60 PLME classmates who were, like, some of the most competitive applicants of, of our year, um, I’m, I hazard a strong guess that a majority [00:42:00] of us had at least one B on our app- on our, uh, transcript at some point.

Anna: Thanks, Katie. Sort of following up on that thread, um, this student had a follow-up question, which is how much weight are grades and SAT or ACT scores given compared to the essays and activities?

Dr. Katie Chiou: Hmm. Uh, I’ve actually … I read, like, a breakdown of it once, which is, like, again, these are all, like, kind of like guesswork. I really do think of it as, like, a gateway thing of, like, if you are far below a school’s median, then the, the truth is that pr- outside of extraneous circumstances, there always are, there’s always extraneous circumstances.

Dr. Katie Chiou: But if you are far outside of a school’s median, then your chances of admission are dropped significantly. But if you’re meeting that median threshold, then beyond that, I think what makes and breaks the difference is, like, the essays and extracurriculars and all of the kind of like the, the personhood of what gets you into a school.[00:43:00]

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, if I had to give it a number, I think of essays as, like, maybe 30%, extracurriculars as 40? No, that’s, that’s too much. I don’t know if you have a better, um, number for it. Maybe like 20% for essays, 30% for extracurriculars. So maybe like 50% to grades and test scores combined, and then 50% to the other t- which, it makes them kind of even.

Dr. Katie Chiou: I don’t know, Anna, do you have like a better, like, numbers breakdown? I’m like- Well- … guessing, everyone would be.

Anna: In terms of numbers, we actually have at CollegeAdvisor, Dr. Aya Waller-Bey. She got her PhD studying the college admissions essay in the US.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Ooh, okay.

Anna: And she surveyed a bunch of admissions officers and asked them to rank the importance of each component of the application, and they all ranked grades very high.

Anna: Um, I think it was like a nine or a 10, and everything else they ranked a five. [00:44:00] So is that helpful? Is it frustrating? I think it’s informative. It means that they are looking at everything and considering everything with about equal value once, like Katie said, you have the gateway of the grades. So I would say grades are most important, and then depending on your profile, you know, maybe you can really swing it with your essays or maybe it’s your extracurriculars, but they’re giving all of those sections attention.

Anna: Um, they’re not skipping any of them. They’re not breezing through, and they’re looking for reasons to accept you, not for reasons to reject you. Um, that’s how they’re reading them. So that’s the best I have in terms of numbers. Um, we are getting a lot of good questions. Thanks, y’all. Let’s see. Katie, as a [00:45:00] sophomore, do you have advice for how a student could start building on their college resume?

Dr. Katie Chiou: Yeah, I, I think as a sophomore there’s room still for you to kind of try a lot of things and then also start to whittle down what you like and you don’t like. I would say that the majority of, like, my main extracurriculars, I didn’t, I didn’t really nail down until … I did like Science Olympia in my sophomore year.

Dr. Katie Chiou: I was at a much, like it was in some lower position, um, on the literary magazine my sophomore year. So there were things that, like, were kinda like burgeoning, like, oh, there’s like I had potential kind of things. Um, and then some other major extracurriculars I didn’t really find until my junior year. Um, I would say one thing to do is to look within your school, but also look at the outside of your school.

Dr. Katie Chiou: So like kind of like have balance of a little bit of both. Um, I would also say that I, and, like, things have changed dramatically as my understanding because AI, [00:46:00] um, but when I was a sophomore, I would spend like my winter breaks literally like trawling the internet looking for different like things that I could do during the summer.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Whether like my sophomore summer or my junior summer, I would find like whatever programs were out there, like if they were free, if they were not free. If you’re a spreadsheet person, you could also make spreadsheets. I am still not a spreadsheet person, so I just bookmarked everything and it was like haphazard way, whatever.

Dr. Katie Chiou: I’m a little chaotic still. Um, the point being that like, to, like you have time but also preparation is necessary to make things successful later on. And a lot of the applications for these summer program type things are due like around February, March. And so if you’re a sophomore now, that means you still have, like you have all of winter ahead of you to do a little bit of that research and prep ahead of time for what you might be interested in doing your sophomore summer and then your junior summer, which some programs are only available your s- your junior summer.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, but yeah, I think my biggest thing is like to try everything and then start to whittle it down and then also kind of get a sense of like, [00:47:00] hey, like what, uh, what could I possibly build into a leadership position and like what is, uh, definitely a lost cause? Um, and sometimes it’s like also what I used to enjoy doing.

Dr. Katie Chiou: I remember doing debate and being like, “Oh, I’m actually not bad at this,” but then it would just cost me so much of my energy and exhaust me to go to debate tournaments. And I was like, “I can’t do this anymore.” And so I quit my sophomore year. Um, but just like, you know, like think ideas of things to try out both inside of school, outside of school, and then really trying to chase after things that like kind of pique your interest.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, I remember I started doing this, like I, I tutored, um, I happened to be tutoring at a domestic violence shelter, so it was like kiddos who had been moving from place to place. Not intentional. I kind of like had found this, again, through trawling the internet. Um, but it was just like something that like, you know, like it was like the name of it like kind of piqued my interest ’cause I could have pursued a, a number of other tutoring things instead, like tutoring at my school, but that was the one that kinda was like, ooh, that sounds interesting.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, and, and kind of like [00:48:00] following those little glimmers, uh, of, of interest.

Anna: Thank you, Katie. I’m gonna give you a little break ’cause you’ve been going strong for almost an hour, um, just so I can have a few minutes to talk about who we are at CollegeAdvisor, because everything we talked about tonight is exactly what our team thinks about and helps students with every day.

Anna: CollegeAdvisor.com has guided more than 10,000 families through the college admissions process. Our team is made up of 200 plus admissions experts and former admissions officers, so our team knows what it actually takes to get that acceptance letter. In the class of 2026 alone, one in three of our Ivy League applicants were admitted to at least one Ivy League school, and two out of three applicants applying to top 25 schools were accepted to one or more.

Anna: To learn more about how you can get started with CollegeAdvisor, scan the QR code on the screen [00:49:00] to sign up for a free 60-minute strategy session with an admission specialist on our team. I’m gonna leave that QR code on the screen while we go back to your questions. Katie, here’s one I get a lot from students.

Anna: Um, we have a student joining us who finds themselves comparing their stats and activities to other applicants, watching YouTube videos saying, “To get into Harvard, you need at least 10 APs. You need to do Science Olympiad, X, Y, and Z.” And the impact on the student is that they’re feeling like they’re not doing enough, and it’s sort of impossible to follow all of the advice out there online.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Yeah.

Anna: What can students do to sort of avoid that type of comparison and stress?

Dr. Katie Chiou: Yeah. Gosh, that’s something that follows you for life, the stress of a comparison, right? Like even I’m so many years later, and I’m a resident, [00:50:00] and it … Like the … It’s still easy to compare myself to what other people are doing and like, “Oh my gosh, am I doing enough?”

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, so it’s like, it’s like certainly a, a monster that chases you. Um, I will say when it comes to college admissions, like, oh, like I- it’s gotten so much worse since I applied with like YouTube and TikTok. Whenever I see them, like, okay, granted I’m not there anymore, but like genuinely I scroll past because I’m like, “I can’t.”

Dr. Katie Chiou: I can’t fall into this hole of like looking at what other people are doing and being like, “Oh my gosh,” like comparing them to myself. And I actually … That actually brings me back to like one of the pieces of advice that I often have for essay writing too, which I know that’s like, like I’m being more specific here.

Dr. Katie Chiou: But, um, when it comes to like reading other people’s essays and being like, “Oh my gosh, like this is an essay that got into Harvard. Like how do I write an essay like that? Like I’ll never be as creative. I’ll never like think of something as like unique as that.” And then, um, sometimes I also see people like make the mistake of like trying to be so like unique that it kind of like flops, um, [00:51:00] almost.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Like I remember, um, once reading an essay like in the form of an acrostic poem, which is like a fine format, except that it was just like, I think it was like the word medicine, and then it was like, “M is for me because I…” W- whatever. The point is like we were … It was … We were trying too hard to like stand out to the point where I was like, “This is-” cringe at this point.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And also, like, n- more importantly, it wasn’t, like, effectively telling me anything about this applicant, and I was like, “I’m not getting anywhere with this. Um, I’ve got nothing.” Uh, so the … I went on a tangent, but the point being that, like, yeah, comparison is, like, I’m sure this is, like, a thief of … Whatever, I’m sure there’s a phrase for it.

Dr. Katie Chiou: But the point being that I would actually limit your consumption a bit. Like, straight up, I would say, like, you likely already know enough. You know more than enough, often, if you’re here at this webinar, um, to be a successful applicant to college. Watching exactly the minutiae of what other people do is not going to be helpful, which is why I keep recommending, like

Dr. Katie Chiou: Like, sometimes I’ll be like upperclassmen, because [00:52:00] upperclassmen are, in some ways, like, not your competition, is what I think about. And also, like, there’s no way that I can achieve all of what I watched the upperclassmen do. Like, I watched people, like, they were, like, going to math competitions. They were doing this and that, and I was like, “Man, these are geniuses.”

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, I did nothing on, like, a significant … Like, I can’t even say that I, like, won any state competitions. Like, not to mention, like, national or, like, international things. Like, I, I think I look back and I’m like, I didn’t, I did not cure can- Like, I didn’t do anything crazy and, and got into a lot of schools because the, at, at the end of the day, like, there are people who are stand out Olympic ice skaters who are getting into things.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And I’m like, “Okay, I’m never gonna be that.” That’s okay. Like, there are plenty of, like, college campuses are filled up of thousands of people who are normal people who are just, like, really interesting and really invested in pr- like intellectually curious and, and like want to make something out of their college careers.

Dr. Katie Chiou: And I think those are [00:53:00] honestly, those are the majority of the people that you end up meeting when you go to college. Um, none of my, like, best friends, maybe unfortunately, but none of them were like Olympic athletes or cured cancer or like were big, I don’t know, like nepot children or anything like that.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, I will also say that like more groundedly when it comes to like essays and actually specific things, look at very specific … Like when it came to essays, I looked at like one website, which was called like the John Hopkins Essays That Worked or some similar thing where an admissions officer has vetted the essay and has put it forth as like, “This essay is amazing.”

Dr. Katie Chiou: I read a couple of those, and then I cut myself off. I remember like literally at 17 being like, “I can’t read anymore because if I read anymore, first of all, I’m gonna be like I have no creative ideas. I got nothing in my … And I’m gonna like start to try to write the essays just like these other people so I, I can like, ’cause I think that’s better.”

Dr. Katie Chiou: Um, I need to cut myself off. And the other thing that I realized was sometimes you’re reading an essay of like, oh, this person got into Harvard, and you’re reading their essay because like, you know, [00:54:00] like people publish like books or like, you know, you can find those essays online. You have no clue if the reason they got in is ’cause of their essay.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Like, for all you know, like they’re also a star athlete, and that’s actually more impressive than their essay. Or maybe like, I don’t know, there’s a billion other reasons why someone gets into college that’s not like the, the specific point of comparison you’re making, whether it’s essays or extracurriculars or grades or something else, right?

Dr. Katie Chiou: And so, um, trying to take a step back from that and being like, “I am the person that I am. Um, and how can I best be the person that I am?” Work in progress.

Anna: Yes. Yes. I tell my students, “Eyes on your own paper.”

Dr. Katie Chiou: Yeah.

Anna: Um, too much comparison is a thief of joy, like Katie said.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Yes. That’s the phrase.

Anna: That’s the phrase.

Anna: And, um, I didn’t read the student’s second question, but it was, you know, is this advice true? Do I need 10 plus APs? Do I need Olympiad awards? And no.

Dr. Katie Chiou: No.

Anna: You don’t. Any, any video, unless they’re [00:55:00] saying you need to fill out the application to completion, which is true.

Dr. Katie Chiou: True.

Anna: Beyond that, any, any statement that you need X to get into Harvard is not true.

Anna: And I would take a step back from that source in general- Yes … because I would question their, their motives. Um.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Yeah. Okay. That’s kind of going back to, like, the fear-mongering, but that, that is- Yeah … just fear-mongering. Like, I had the … My, like, freshman pod neighbor, I remember he … I don’t know why I know this.

Dr. Katie Chiou: I don’t know this for everyone, but this … He had happened to take three AP. So clearly … Like, not the 10, like, or whatever number that someone had invented. Um, I don’t think either did … My roommate also didn’t take 10 APs. Like, it’s, it, there’s … Like, there’s a reason why we don’t give a number, because there is not a number.

Anna: Yeah. My school didn’t offer APs. Mm-hmm. And not all of them do, and admissions officers know that. Yeah. Um, all right. We have time for a few more maybe. Um, Katie, where would you say is a good source [00:56:00] for students to figure out each university’s culture or vibe?

Dr. Katie Chiou: Ooh. That’s, um … I wish … I honestly have to say, like, I bet my answer is super outdated, because I haven’t been in college in years.

Dr. Katie Chiou: Back, um, s- back in my day, it was, like, Facebook meme pages. I don’t know w- if, like, that still exists, but, like, the, sometimes the best way to suss out culture is, like, like stereotypes to some extent. This is, like, for, for vibes only. Not just, not, like, specifically for essays, but for vibes only. Like, if you can find wherever the kids are these days with, like, the jokes and, like, I

Dr. Katie Chiou: Like, we had, like, an Ivy League meme page, and, like, it was always, like, I don’t know, it was pretty on point. Like, it always is. Um, there are … Like, you could also, um … I remember some people were really on College Confidential. I was never a col- … Like, that’s an example of, like, comparison, thief of joy. Never

Dr. Katie Chiou: Was like that’s, that’s a hard boundary for me, never going on the website. [00:57:00] Um, but sometimes, like, if you do wanna watch, ah, I, I actually find that these, like, vlog of influencers, um, being at, at … Like, a day in my life as a Harvard student actually isn’t that emblematic of the vibes of the campus. Sometimes, like, I’ll come across, like, TikToks where it’s like, “Oh,” like, “if you’re at this school,” like, “here are the vibes.”

Dr. Katie Chiou: Sometimes those are, like n- like, they’re not perfectly accurate, but they’re, like, they’re s- they’re kind of like the new meme thing, um, or it’s like with these TikToks. Um, that’s, that’s somewhere I, I would say that you could go. And then for essay specifically, that’s going to be, like, doing, like, your in-depth googling and research.

Dr. Katie Chiou: That’s less, like, vibes and more, like, specific things that you can mention, specific classes, specific professors. Like, talking to people, like, what are strong departments at this school? That’s all … That requires, like, boots on the ground research, not just TikToks.

Anna: Yes. And I always tell my students, if you’re able to do a tour-

Dr. Katie Chiou: Mm

Anna: that’s a great way, right? And I … If you [00:58:00] can, talk to a student who isn’t the tour guide- Yes … who isn’t being paid to tell you that that school is amazing, uh, can really give you some good insight. Um, okay. Maybe one more question, Katie. If you’re involved in an extracurricular and you have multiple leadership roles within that organization, would you list that under one activity or could that count as more than one?

Dr. Katie Chiou: Hmm. Okay. And I’m also, like, seeing this question in front of me, and it’s mentioning 4H specifically, and I’m gonna be totally honest, I actually don’t know that much about 4H and the things that you mentioned. I would say in general, let’s say if I, for example, w- So basically, this is a, like a very nit- like a very m- detail-oriented, um, question, so I kind of have a nitpicky answer, which is to say that when you actually fill out your Common Application, you can actually go and make, like, an account that [00:59:00] won’t, like

Dr. Katie Chiou: That it can be, like, it will just be obsolete by the time you actually apply, so you can actually look at it. But there’s, like, a section that’s typically for, like, extracurricular name, and a section for, like, extracurricular title, and it has a certain amount of characters. So you can actually put multiple things into those, like, headliner sections.

Dr. Katie Chiou: So for example, um, for, um, the literary magazine I r- I mentioned, um, I was editor-in-chief at, like, my peak, but before that I was, like, the poetry editor, for example. So I actually was able to put both of those words and fit it into those character limits. Um, or I think there’s a section, like, for Science Olympia, I wrote specifically, like, what events I had medaled in.

Dr. Katie Chiou: So I, like, was able to say, like, specifically, like, what events that I had placed in. I think that was in, like, some ki- like, some headliner description area. Um, so there’s, uh, there’s, there is space for you to put multiple positions and multiple, um, things if it’s under one extra- co- extracurricular. [01:00:00] At the end of the day, what’s going to happen is you are going to be a senior, you are going to sit down, you’re going to write out all of your extracurriculars you’ve ever done in your entire life.

Dr. Katie Chiou: You’re gonna add on a couple more silly ones that you are like, “Oh.” Like, for me, I was like, “Oh, maybe I’ll put singing on there. I don’t know. Maybe I’ll put, like, volun- like, political canvassing on there. I don’t know.” Um, and then you kind of like, you’ll kind of mash them around and figure out what order you wanna put them in.

Dr. Katie Chiou: You’ll figure out, like, where things might be one extracurricular, where you can combine them, or you might separate them out. Um, and so it will, it will all ultimately flesh out in itself. Um, and so if, for example, you, um … Yeah, but basically if it, if it’s like a r- like a promotion of leadership, then I kind of tend to list that under one thing.

Dr. Katie Chiou: If they’re, like, very significantly different, um- things that you are doing, then you could maybe list them as separate extracurriculars.

Anna: Yeah. Neither would be held against you. Yeah, exactly. I think it, it’s gonna come down to, like Katie said, are you trying to fill all 10 or are you trying to [01:01:00] squeeze more in to all 10?

Dr. Katie Chiou: Yes, exactly.

Anna: Uh, thank you all so much for coming out tonight, for your great questions. Thank you, Katie, for your expertise. If you haven’t been able to scan the QR code to schedule your free assessment with us, please keep your browser open, and when the webinar officially ends, you’ll be redirected to our booking page.

Anna: We’d love to get connected and chat with you one-on-one. Um, but I’m gonna end the webinar for now. We had a really great time talking about admissions with you, and best of luck, everyone, on your applications. Yeah. Bye, everyone.